MVY Shopping Guide
Where to Shop on Martha’s Vineyard
Overview
We’re happy to share our Ultimate Guide to Shopping on Martha’s Vineyard!
The island offers many different activities that truly encompass the paradisiacal feel of this marvelous place, and that includes the diverse shopping experience. When shopping on Martha’s Vineyard, you’ll find a range of options for browsing handmade items, souvenirs, upscale clothing, and more.
What you won’t find much of, generally speaking, is “cheap” stuff. This is probably not surprising, but it needs to be mentioned that we don’t have a lot of chains and definitely no Marshalls, TJ Maxx, WalMart, or Target. It’s just not how we roll, but don’t worry, we’ll share some great spots for bargains in the mix. They are here if you knew where to look!
If you’re up for a memorable shopping stroll in our main areas, you can explore Circuit Avenue in Oak Bluffs, or the Main Streets of Vineyard Haven and Edgartown.
On this page, we’ll delve into each distinctive shopping experience so that you may find exactly what you’re looking for. OK! Let’s get shopping, shall we?!
BY: Jenna @ExploreMVY
PUBLISHED: June 25, 2024
LAST UPDATE: June 26, 2024
PAGE CONTENTS
Click to jump to a topic here:
Main Shopping Areas
Island Name Brands
Gifts & Souvenirs
Clothing Basics
Boutique Clothing
Thrift & Consignment
Jewelry
Outdoors
Kitchen & Décor
Farm/Agricultural
Main Shopping Areas
There are three main shopping destinations on the island for the perfect spree:
Circuit Ave in Oak Bluffs: If you’re looking for a bustling retail adventure that includes essential clothing items, souvenirs, and sweet treats, Circuit Ave is the perfect spot for your needs. Circuit Avenue is definitely known to be more tourist-centered, as it is located in the busy Oak Bluffs, so you can be sure to find energy and excitement while you shop. If you are bringing a car, be sure to know how to parallel park, as the parking design was changed in 2022.
Main Street in Vineyard Haven: For a more leisurely shopping experience infused with local charm, Main Street is the way to go. Here, you’ll find unique clothing pieces, handmade goods, coastal-inspired home decor, and timeless accessories and jewelry that embody the essence of island lifestyle.
Edgartown: Edgartown has the largest shopping area out of the three, with a wide selection of places to find preppy clothing, luxurious accessories, and unique artwork. You might keep in mind, however, that the higher price tags often reflect the quality.
Island Name Brands
Embrace the islander style with these rapidly growing brands founded right here on Martha’s Vineyard! There is no better place to shop these popular styles than where it was first inspired and created.
Vineyard Vines, founded in 1998 on Martha’s Vineyard by a pair of brothers, is known for its preppy pastel styles and its iconic pink whale logo. This brand has flourished to be well-known across the country and is now the official style of Kentucky Derby, the Premier Lacrosse League, and the Head of the Charles Regatta. Vineyard Vines offers a wide range of clothing and accessories for the whole family. Find stores on the island in Oak Bluffs, Vineyard Haven, and Edgartown.
Based on a captain’s love for the island, the ocean, and his dog, The Black Dog is a casual brand that started in 1971 as a tavern that welcomed locals and visitors with great food. The Black Dog taverns and bakery cafés can still be visited around the island, but it has also expanded into a popular casual clothing brand. Here, you’ll find cozy sweatshirts, t-shirts, hats, dog accessories, and more with the image of a black labrador retriever on it. Find stores on the island in Oak Bluffs, Vineyard Haven, and Edgartown.
Menemsha Blues, inspired by the fishing town of Menemsha, began in 1994. It offers comfortable clothing with an aesthetic that combines a nautical and relaxed feel. If you’re looking for clothing pieces that reflect the peacefulness of the island’s oceanside, Menemsha Blues is the brand for you. Find stores on the island in Vineyard Haven and Chilmark.
Gifts & Souvenirs
Discover the perfect memento to remember your time on Martha’s Vineyard by, or find a great gift that will make someone smile:
Rainy Day (Vineyard Haven): Find humorous and quirky gifts, along with a great selection of kids’ clothing, home decor, and accessories at this boutique.
Sanctuary (Oak Bluffs): This small shop located on Circuit Avenue offers a variety of simple coastal-inspired home decor and jewelry.
The Lazy Frog (Oak Bluffs): If you are looking for something to keep the kids busy, Lazy Frog has all of your answers with a selection of games, toys, and sporting gear.
Mardells Gifts & Jewelry (Vineyard Haven): If you’re looking for some travel-friendly gifts or souvenirs to bring home with you, check out the more budget-friendly but lovely options from Mardell’s, including jewelry, stationary, and souvenirs.
Clothing Basics
Accidentally leave your bathing suit at home? Looking for island-inspired clothing essentials but want to be reasonable on your budget? Here are two of our favorite spots for everyday staples:
Soft as a Grape (Oak Bluffs, Edgartown, Vineyard Haven): Discover high-quality, casual Martha’s Vineyard clothing items.
Basics & Eastaway Clothing (Oak Bluffs): Find clothing essentials for every wardrobe need, from bathing suits to shoes to dresses, at these neighboring shops.
Boutique Clothing
Experience a shopping spree like no other by exploring the unique pieces of Martha’s Vineyard boutiques. Poke into Kenworthy, Suka Boutique, Katydid, Rags, or Lani Beach Club for your next island-inspired outfit. Or, experience one-of-a-kind flannels from Mikel Hunter or luxurious espadrilles crafted from designer scarves from Respoke.
Edgartown:
Kenworthy (Edgartown): Explore timeless, sustainable pieces inspired by textiles with this mother-daughter collaboration boutique.
Suka Boutique (Edgartown): If you’re looking for a stylish piece to grow your wardrobe, look no further than this women-owned, lifestyle boutique.
Katydid (Edgartown): If you’re looking for a patterned bag, colorful jewelry piece, or a cute summer dress that is sure to be the talk of your next outing, Katydid has it all! Or, if you are shopping for kids, grab an island-themed pajama set so they have dreams as beautiful as the Vineyard.
Rags (Edgartown): This upscale boutique, to the contrary of its name, carries beautiful finds to spruce up your closet. Find vibrant dresses, coastal styled basics, and sun hats to make your summer even brighter.
Mikel Hunter (Edgartown): You’re sure to find something one-of-a-kind at Mikel Hunter, who carries exclusive accessories and collaboration pieces.
Respoke (Edgartown): At Respoke, find your next favorite footwear, with the peace of mind that each pair is sustainably crafted and repurposed with designer brand scarves.
Oak Bluffs:
Blush Boutique (Oak Bluffs): Celebrate femininity and boost your confidence with a special piece from Blush, whether it’s a summer dress or a cute top for a night out with the girls.
Megan’s Boutique (Oak Bluffs): Find trendy women’s fashion and accessories at Megan’s Boutique.
Island Outfitters (Oak Bluffs): Grab some island-inspired basics such as sandals, bathing suits, and beachy accessories.
Vineyard Haven:
The Seven Sisters (Vineyard Haven): Shop sustainably at The Seven Sisters with a selection of home décor, accessories, and clothing made to last.
Magnetic North (Vineyard Haven): Complete with a coffee stand in the back of the shop run by Behind the Bookstore, Magnetic North offers an array of men and women’s apparel that make it difficult to resist taking them all home with you.
Lani Beach Club (Vineyard Haven): Recycled from ocean plastics, Lani Beach Club is the perfect place to shop beachwear and accessories while keeping the planet in mind.
Thrift & Consignment
For the savvy shopper with an eye for vintage finds and sustainable shopping gems, Martha’s Vineyard offers several thrift and consignment locations:
Boutique on the Buy Way (Oak Bluffs): Located in the Dockside Marketplace of the Oak Bluffs harbor, this boutique find is a hidden gem with gently loved, upscale brand name items. Find your next staple piece, or treat yourself to a luxurious steal. A great thing to know about Boutique on the Buy Way is that they are not only environmentally friendly, but they also serve the local community by donating unsold items - All the more reason to support this fantastic second-hand boutique!
Act Two Second Hand Store (Vineyard Haven): Act Two Second Hand Store is a non-profit that supports education in the arts on Martha’s Vineyard. When you purchase from Act Two, you are not only supporting a great cause, but you are also helping the environment by giving a piece of furniture, jewelry, art, or houseware item a second “act”!
Chicken Alley (Vineyard Haven)
Jewelry
Always have a piece of Martha’s Vineyard on you with jewelry crafted with love right here on the island:
CB Stark (Vineyard Haven, Edgartown): Voted the island’s “Best Jeweler” every year since 1996, CB Stark is a very much loved destination for jewelry needs that truly encompass the unique charm of Martha’s Vineyard. From skunk charms to iconic island-shaped earrings, CB Stark creates beautiful and timeless pieces for all.
Claudia (Vineyard Haven, Edgartown): Featuring jewelry from local artisans, perfumes, accessories, and hand-blown glass, Claudia is the one-stop-shop to find luxurious pieces to add to your collection or to find the most special gift.
Stefanie Wolf Designs (Oak Bluffs): Step into a world of color at Stefanie Wolf Designs, where you’ll find pieces made with glass beads handmade in the Czech Republic, a wide selection of sterling silver rings, beautiful pearls, and more.
Hawk House (Online): Discover unique, island-made crystal jewelry for every zodiac sign or birthstone. These pieces are electroformed, meaning that the material is formed around the crystal - how cool!
Dockside Jewelers (Oak Bluffs): Add some sparkle to your life with a timeless, island-inspired piece from Dockside Jewelers.
Whatever Sterling Silver (Edgartown): If you’re a silver-jewelry-person, you will truly find whatever you may be looking for at Whatever Sterling Silver, which offers a wide selection of unique and hand-selected pieces.
Outdoors
The Green Room (Vineyard Haven): Equip yourself for your next adventure by stopping by The Green Room in Vineyard Haven, which has all of your surfing, skateboarding, and beach trip needs taken care of in one spot.
Kitchen & Décor
LeRoux at Home (Vineyard Haven): Who knew houseware and décor could be so exciting — see for yourself when you step into LeRoux! With a magnificent selection of their own brand of olive oils and vinegars (you can taste test in the store!), kitchen gadgets you didn’t know you needed (onion goggles?), and gorgeous dishes, LeRoux is certainly a store you won’t want to miss.
Farm/Agricultural
Morning Glory Farm (West Tisbury): Enjoy island-grown fruits, veggies, and other goods produced on the farm and sold at their year-round farmstand, bakery, and kitchen.
Island Alpaca Company (Vineyard Haven): Take a fluffy piece of the island home with you after you visit with the alpacas of Martha’s Vineyard. Find warm socks, hats, sweaters, and mittens made with cloud-like alpaca fleece.
The Grey Barn & Farm (Chilmark): Grab a taste of the island with high-quality products made right in this family-owned farm’s creamery and bakery.